Fixing Common Winemaking Issues with Ease

2.2K

Discover expert solutions to common winemaking problems from stuck fermentations to hazy wine, off-flavors, and more. Learn prevention techniques and rescue strategies to save your homemade wine and improve future batches.

The Art and Science of Troubleshooting Wine

Winemaking is often romanticized as a perfect blend of art and science, resulting in a beautiful expression of terroir and craftsmanship. The reality, however, is that even experienced winemakers occasionally face batches that don’t quite go according to plan. Perhaps the fermentation stalls unexpectedly, strange aromas develop, or the finished wine lacks clarity despite your best efforts. These moments of uncertainty are not just challenges—they’re valuable learning opportunities that will ultimately make you a better winemaker.

“The true skill in winemaking isn’t avoiding problems altogether—it’s knowing how to recognize, diagnose, and address issues when they arise,” explains Deborah Golino, Director of Foundation Plant Services at UC Davis. “Even professional winemakers with decades of experience occasionally encounter unexpected complications.”

The good news is that most common winemaking problems have well-established solutions. With the right knowledge and a systematic approach to troubleshooting, you can rescue troubled batches and prevent similar issues in the future. Whether you’re working with fresh grapes, juice, or kits, understanding the science behind what went wrong empowers you to make thoughtful corrections rather than panicking or, worse, discarding a salvageable batch.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through the most common winemaking problems, explaining their causes, prevention strategies, and—when things do go awry—practical rescue techniques. From stuck fermentations and clarity issues to off-flavors and aromas, we’ll provide you with the knowledge to tackle almost any winemaking challenge with confidence.

Fermentation Failures: When Activity Stalls

Fermentation problems are among the most common and concerning issues that home winemakers face. Let’s examine the primary fermentation challenges and how to address them:

Stuck Fermentations: When Sugar Remains

A stuck fermentation—when yeast activity slows or stops before reaching the desired dryness—can leave you with an overly sweet wine lacking balance and stability.

Identifying Stuck Fermentations

• Specific gravity readings remain unchanged for 2-3 days
• Residual sweetness despite extended fermentation time
• Lack of visible activity (no bubbling in airlock) while wine still tastes sweet
• Fermentation stops with hydrometer reading above 1.000 (dry wine typically finishes at 0.990-0.998)

According to research from Cornell University’s Viticulture and Enology Program, approximately 60% of stuck fermentations are due to nutrient deficiencies, while temperature issues account for roughly 25% of cases.

Common Causes

1. Nutrient Deficiencies: Insufficient nitrogen (YAN) for yeast metabolism
2. Temperature Extremes: Too cold slows yeast; too hot can kill yeast
3. High Starting Sugar: Osmotic pressure stressing yeast cells
4. Alcohol Toxicity: Reaching yeast’s alcohol tolerance threshold
5. Low pH: Extremely acidic environment inhibiting yeast activity
6. Wild Yeast Competition: Indigenous yeasts creating toxic environment for cultured yeast

“The most successful interventions for stuck fermentations involve addressing multiple potential causes simultaneously,” notes Lisa Van de Water, wine microbiologist and consultant to the wine industry.

Prevention Strategies

• Proper Nutrient Management: Add yeast nutrients according to manufacturer specifications
• Staged Nutrient Additions: Add nutrients in increments rather than all at once
• Temperature Control: Maintain steady temperatures within yeast’s optimal range
• Yeast Selection: Choose strains with appropriate alcohol tolerance for your style
• Proper Rehydration: Follow manufacturer’s instructions for yeast rehydration
• Oxygen Management: Ensure adequate oxygen during the first 1/3 of fermentation

Rescue Techniques

For mild stuck fermentations (less than 10-20 g/L residual sugar):

1. The Temperature Adjustment Method:
   • Warm the wine to 70-75°F (21-24°C)
   • Gently stir to release CO₂ and resuspend yeast
   • Monitor for 24-48 hours for resumed activity
2. The Nutrient Boost Protocol:
   • Add complex yeast nutrient (not just DAP)
   • Gently stir to incorporate and release CO₂
   • Keep warm and monitor for activity

For severely stuck fermentations:

1. The Restart Method:
   • Prepare a “starter” with active, alcohol-tolerant yeast (like EC-1118)
   • Create an acclimation sequence:
     • 1 part stuck wine + 1 part water + nutrients
     • Allow to start fermenting
     • Gradually add more stuck wine (doubling volume each step)
     • Finally add to the main batch when actively fermenting

According to research from UC Davis Department of Viticulture and Enology, this gradual acclimation method increases restart success rates from approximately 50% to over 90% compared to simply adding new yeast directly.

Sluggish Fermentations: When Progress Is Too Slow

Sometimes fermentation proceeds, but at an agonizingly slow pace:

Identifying Sluggish Fermentations

• Less than 2 Brix/day decrease during primary fermentation
• Minimal visible activity despite temperature being in optimal range
• Gravity readings showing very slow progress (less than 0.002 SG decrease per day)

Common Causes

• Borderline nutrient levels (not quite deficient enough to cause complete stalling)
• Temperature at low end of yeast’s range
• Weak or old yeast culture
• Excessive SO₂ addition pre-fermentation
• Challenging must composition (high acid, low pH)

Solutions

• Increase temperature within yeast’s optimal range
• Add yeast nutrients (focus on complex nutrients, not just DAP)
• Provide gentle aeration/oxygenation if early in fermentation
• Ensure proper pH range (adjust if below 3.2)
• Consider adding yeast hulls for detoxification

“Sluggish fermentations often respond well to simple interventions, but timing is critical,” explains <a href=”https://brewmybeer.online/advanced-wine-making-working-with-different-grape-varieties/” target=”_blank”>winemaking consultant</a> Clark Smith. “The longer you wait to address the issue, the more challenging it becomes to correct.”

Clarity Concerns: When Wine Stays Cloudy

Hazy wine can be both visually unappealing and a sign of stability issues:

Identifying Persistent Haziness

Different types of haze require different solutions:

Pectic Haze

• Appears as a general cloudiness that doesn’t settle
• More common in fruit wines and some white grape varieties
• Will not clear with time or normal fining agents

Protein Haze

• Can appear clear when cold but becomes cloudy when warmed
• More common in white wines
• May disappear and reappear with temperature changes

Microbial Haze

• Generally uniform cloudiness
• May have off-aromas accompanying the haziness
• May worsen over time rather than improve

Tartrate Crystals

• Not actually haze, but can be mistaken for cloudiness
• Form diamond-like crystals that settle to the bottom
• More common after refrigeration

“Understanding the specific type of clarity issue is crucial for selecting the right solution,” notes Chik Brenneman, former winemaker and manager of the UC Davis teaching winery. “Different hazes require fundamentally different treatments.”

Prevention Strategies

Preventing clarity issues is easier than correcting them:

• Cold Stabilization: Chill wine to near freezing for 1-2 weeks before bottling
• Protein Stability: Use bentonite during or after fermentation for white wines
• Pectic Enzyme Addition: Add at crush for fruit wines and some grape varieties
• Proper Fining: Use appropriate fining agents based on wine type
• Patience: Allow adequate aging time for natural clarification
• Effective Filtration: Consider appropriate filtration methods for your wine style

According to Purdue University’s Wine Grape Team, nearly 80% of clarity issues can be prevented with proper pre-fermentation treatments and patience during aging.

Rescue Techniques

For wines with persistent clarity issues:

For Pectic Haze

1. Test for pectin presence (mix 1 part wine with 3 parts denatured alcohol; jellylike precipitate confirms pectin)
2. Add pectic enzyme at higher dose than normal
3. Keep wine warm (65-70°F/18-21°C) for enzyme activity
4. Allow 1-2 weeks for clearing

For Protein Haze

1. Conduct bentonite trial to determine minimum effective dose
2. Prepare bentonite slurry (mix with hot water, let hydrate for 24 hours)
3. Add to wine and stir thoroughly
4. Allow to settle for 1-2 weeks before racking

For Microbial Haze

1. Test for microbial presence (microscopic examination or lab test)
2. If confirmed, consider sterile filtration (0.45 micron or finer)
3. Ensure adequate SO₂ levels for protection
4. Consider adding lysozyme for bacterial hazes

“Even extremely cloudy wines can usually be rescued with the right approach,” encourages Alison Crowe, Director of Winemaking for Plata Wine Partners and author of “The Winemaker’s Answer Book.” “The key is identifying the specific cause rather than trying random fixes.”

Aroma and Flavor Faults: Rescuing Off-Aromas

Perhaps the most concerning wine problems are those affecting aroma and flavor. Here’s how to address common sensory faults:

Hydrogen Sulfide (H₂S): The Rotten Egg Problem

This unpleasant aroma is relatively common and responsive to treatment:

Identifying H₂S

• Distinct rotten egg smell
• May range from slight to overpowering
• Often develops during fermentation or shortly after

According to a study published in the American Journal of Enology and Viticulture, approximately 25-30% of wine fermentations develop detectable H₂S at some point, though most resolve naturally.

Common Causes

• Nutrient deficiencies (particularly nitrogen and vitamins)
• Certain yeast strains prone to H₂S production
• Excessive sulfur-containing fungicides on grapes
• Excessive amount of elemental sulfur applied in vineyard
• Extended contact with gross lees under reductive conditions

Prevention Strategies

• Proper nutrient management with balanced nutrients
• Yeast strain selection (low H₂S producers)
• Adequate oxygenation during early fermentation
• Minimizing SO₂ additions before fermentation
• Avoiding extended lees contact without stirring

Rescue Techniques

For mild H₂S (recent development):

1. Copper Treatment Test:
   • Place a clean copper penny in a glass of wine
   • Swirl and smell after a few minutes
   • If smell improves, copper treatment may work
2. Aeration Treatment:
   • Splash rack with deliberate aeration
   • Often sufficient for mild, recent cases
   • Monitor carefully to avoid oxidation

For moderate to severe H₂S:

1. Copper Sulfate Treatment:
   • Prepare 1% copper sulfate solution
   • Add in increments of 0.1-0.2 mL per liter
   • Test between additions to find minimum effective dose
   • Rack off any copper sulfide precipitate
   • Follow with fining to remove excess copper

“Copper treatments should be used judiciously and as a last resort,” warns Gordon Burns of ETS Laboratories. “Excessive copper can cause problems of its own and potentially exceed legal limits.”

Volatile Acidity (VA): The Vinegar Problem

When acetic acid bacteria convert alcohol to acetic acid, the resulting vinegar notes can ruin wine:

Identifying VA

• Aromas ranging from heightened fruitiness (low levels) to vinegar (high levels)
• Acrid, sharp quality on the palate
• Reduced freshness and fruit expression

Common Causes

• Oxygen exposure during aging
• Acetobacter contamination
• Poor sanitation practices
• Low SO₂ levels
• Damaged/moldy fruit

Prevention Strategies

• Maintain appropriate SO₂ levels
• Minimize headspace in storage vessels
• Practice rigorous sanitation
• Sort fruit carefully to remove damaged berries
• Control fruit flies and other vectors

Rescue Techniques

For mild VA (below sensory threshold but rising):

• Ensure adequate SO₂ levels
• Top up containers to eliminate headspace
• Lower storage temperature if possible

For moderate VA:

1. Blending: Blend with unaffected wine to dilute VA
2. Reverse Osmosis: Professional treatment to physically remove VA
3. Masking: Slight sweetening can mask low levels of VA in some styles

According to Washington State University’s Viticulture and Enology Program, once VA exceeds 0.7 g/L (as acetic acid), it becomes increasingly difficult to treat effectively without specialized equipment.

Oxidation: When Wine Loses Freshness

Oxidized wine loses its varietal character and freshness, developing nutty, sherried characteristics:

Identifying Oxidation

• Loss of fresh fruit aroma
• Development of bruised apple, nutty, or sherried notes
• Color shifting to brownish tones
• Flattened flavor profile

Common Causes

• Excessive air exposure during racking or aging
• Inadequate SO₂ levels
• Headspace in storage containers
• Faulty closures allowing air ingress
• Extended aging of wines with low phenolic content

Prevention Strategies

• Maintain appropriate free SO₂ levels
• Use inert gas to displace oxygen
• Keep containers topped up
• Practice gentle handling techniques
• Monitor and replace questionable closures

Rescue Techniques

For mild oxidation:

1. SO₂ Adjustment:
   • Test and adjust SO₂ to appropriate levels
   • This can halt further oxidation but won’t reverse existing damage
2. Blending:
   • Blend with fresher wine of similar style
   • Often the most practical approach for home winemakers

For moderate oxidation:

1. Treat with Ascorbic Acid:
   • Add ascorbic acid in conjunction with SO₂
   • Can help with recently oxidized wines
2. Stylistic Adaptation:
   • Consider embracing oxidative character for certain styles
   • Some wines (like Tawny Port or Sherry styles) intentionally develop oxidative notes

“Some degree of oxidation is inevitable in all wines over time,” explains Dr. Andrew Waterhouse, professor of enology at UC Davis. “The key is managing the rate to ensure the wine reaches its peak before oxidative character becomes dominant.”

Microbial Contamination: Dealing with Unwanted Microorganisms

Various microorganisms can create serious quality issues in wine:

Brett Character: When Yeasts Go Wild

Brettanomyces contamination can be positive in small amounts but problematic in excess:

Identifying Brett

• Aromas ranging from “barnyard” and “horse blanket” to “medicinal” or “Band-Aid”
• Mousy or metallic aftertaste in severe cases
• Often develops during aging rather than fermentation

Common Causes

• Contaminated barrels
• Poor sanitation practices
• Inadequate SO₂ management
• Cross-contamination from other wines

Prevention Strategies

• Maintain adequate SO₂ levels, especially in barrels
• Practice rigorous sanitation
• Consider sterile filtration for at-risk wines
• Test barrels for Brett contamination

Rescue Techniques

1. Filtration: Sterile filtration (0.45 micron or smaller)
2. SO₂ Addition: Raise free SO₂ to halt further development
3. Stylistic Integration: In mild cases, consider blending or embracing as complexity
4. Velcorin Treatment: Professional DMDC treatment (not available to home winemakers)

“Brett character is particularly challenging because it’s sometimes considered desirable in small amounts,” notes wine microbiologist Dr. Lucy Joseph. “This subjectivity makes decisions about treatment more complex than with straightforward faults.”

Malolactic Issues: When Bacteria Misbehave

Problems with malolactic fermentation (MLF) can create quality and stability issues:

Identifying MLF Problems

• Stuck or sluggish MLF: wine remains high in malic acid
• Unwanted MLF: buttery aromas in wines where MLF isn’t desired
• Excessive diacetyl (butter) character even in wines where MLF is appropriate

Common Causes

• Temperature too cold for ML bacteria
• Low pH inhibiting bacterial activity
• Excessive SO₂ levels
• Competition from other microorganisms
• Nutrient deficiencies

Prevention Strategies

• Inoculate with commercial ML bacteria for controlled MLF
• Maintain appropriate temperature (65-75°F/18-24°C) for MLF
• Use ML nutrients when needed
• Ensure SO₂ levels are low enough to permit MLF
• Conduct MLF before heavy SO₂ additions

Rescue Techniques

For stuck MLF:

1. Re-inoculate: Use robust ML bacteria strain
2. Adjust Temperature: Warm to 68-72°F (20-22°C)
3. Add ML Nutrient: Provide specific nutrients for ML bacteria
4. Consider Co-inoculation: For future batches, adding ML bacteria during primary fermentation can be more reliable

For unwanted MLF:

1. Sterile Filtration: Remove bacteria
2. SO₂ Addition: Add sufficient SO₂ to inhibit ML activity
3. Cold Stabilization: Reduce temperature to slow bacterial activity
4. Lysozyme Addition: Enzyme that can disrupt bacterial cell walls

pH and Acid Balance Issues: When Numbers Are Off

Improper acid levels can affect everything from microbial stability to flavor balance:

High pH/Low Acid Wines

Wines with insufficient acid can taste flat and have stability issues:

Identifying High pH Issues

• pH above 3.8 for red wines or 3.5 for white wines
• Flat, flabby taste lacking vibrancy
• Reduced color stability in red wines
• Increased microbial vulnerability

Common Causes

• Hot growing conditions reducing natural acidity
• Certain grape varieties naturally lower in acid
• Complete malolactic fermentation
• Potassium-rich soils in vineyard

Solutions

1. Acid Addition:
   • Tartaric acid preferred (most stable)
   • Add incrementally with bench trials to determine optimal amount
   • Typically 1-3 g/L additions, depending on starting pH
   • Re-test pH after acid has integrated (24+ hours)
2. Blending:
   • Blend with higher acid wine
   • Often creates more balanced result than acid additions alone

According to researchers at UC Davis Department of Viticulture and Enology, wines with pH above 3.9 require approximately 35% more free SO₂ to achieve the same antimicrobial protection as wines at pH 3.4.

Low pH/High Acid Wines

Excessively acidic wines can be harsh and unbalanced:

Identifying Low pH Issues

• pH below 3.1
• Sharp, tart, sometimes sour taste
• Harsh mouthfeel
• Suppressed fruit character

Common Causes

• Cool climate growing conditions
• Early harvest decisions
• Certain high-acid grape varieties
• Incomplete malolactic fermentation

Solutions

1. Malolactic Fermentation:
   • Inoculate with ML bacteria to reduce malic acid
   • Most effective for wines with high malic acid content
2. Chemical Deacidification:
   • Potassium bicarbonate or calcium carbonate
   • Perform bench trials to determine optimal amount
   • Typically 0.5-2 g/L additions
   • Allow time for tartrate precipitation after treatment
3. Blending:
   • Blend with lower acid wine
   • Often the most natural-tasting solution

“Acid adjustments should be made thoughtfully and incrementally,” advises Jennie Savits, oenologist and consultant. “It’s much easier to add more acid later than to correct an excessive addition.”

Color Issues: When Appearance Disappoints

Wine color can indicate both quality and potential issues:

Color Loss in Red Wines

When red wines lose their vibrant color too quickly:

Identifying Color Issues

• Premature browning at the rim
• Rapid shift from purple to brick red in young wines
• Dull, rather than vibrant, appearance

Common Causes

• Oxidation
• High pH (above 3.8)
• Insufficient phenolic compounds
• Exposure to heat or light
• Certain spoilage microorganisms

Prevention and Remedies

• Ensure adequate SO₂ levels
• Adjust pH to 3.5-3.7 range for better color stability
• Consider tannin additions for structure
• Use micro-oxygenation techniques (commercial winemaking)
• Protect wine from heat and light

“Color stability in red wines is closely linked to pH,” explains Dr. Roger Boulton of UC Davis. “A difference of just 0.2 pH units can dramatically affect anthocyanin equilibrium and color expression.”

Pinking in White Wines

When white wines develop a pinkish tinge:

Identifying Pinking

• Development of pink or salmon hues in white wine
• Most common in certain varieties (Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay)
• Often occurs after bottling or during aging

Common Causes

• Oxidation of certain phenolic compounds
• Trace amounts of anthocyanins from red grape contamination
• Enzymatic browning reactions

Prevention and Remedies

• Use ascorbic acid in conjunction with SO₂
• Consider PVPP fining to remove pinking precursors
• Ensure adequate free SO₂ levels
• Protect from oxygen exposure

According to research from the Australian Wine Research Institute, approximately 20% of white wines show some tendency toward pinking, with the phenomenon being more common in cool-climate regions.

The Resilient Winemaker

Winemaking challenges are inevitable, but they need not be devastating. With the right knowledge, tools, and techniques, most common wine problems can be effectively addressed or even turned to your advantage. After all, some of the world’s most interesting wine styles—from flor-aged sherries to botrytized sweet wines—originated from what might have initially seemed like “problems.”

The key to successful troubleshooting lies in:

1. Early Detection: Regular tasting, testing, and monitoring
2. Accurate Diagnosis: Understanding the true cause rather than just treating symptoms
3. Proportional Response: Using the minimal intervention necessary
4. Prevention: Applying lessons learned to improve future batches

As you gain experience, you’ll develop not only technical skills but also the confidence to make sound decisions when faced with unexpected developments in your winemaking journey. Remember that even professional winemakers encounter challenges—what distinguishes them is not the absence of problems, but the ability to address them effectively.

In the words of renowned winemaker André Tchelistcheff, “Wine is constant proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy, even when things don’t go according to plan.” Embrace the learning opportunities that challenges present, and you’ll become not just a more skilled technician, but a more intuitive and creative winemaker.

---

Author: Olivia Barrelton
Email: olivia.barrelton@brewmybeer.online
Barrel Aging & Wood Infusion Expert at Brew My Beer. Olivia comes from three generations of coopers (barrel makers) and brings unmatched expertise in wood aging techniques to the brewing world. After apprenticing at distilleries in Scotland and wineries in France, she applied her knowledge of wood influences to beer aging.